Was Apartheid rewarded with a football tournament?

5 06 2013

The European U21s football championship has just started. If things had gone to plan I would have been writing about the tournament’s opening match in the Liberty Stadium. I would have been speculating about which teams would make it to the CCS final or proffering an opinion about Wales’ prospects. Sadly I’m not speculating. UEFA awarded the championships to Israel and made me feel uneasy instead.

The opening paragraph isn’t a lament about yet another crushing blow to Welsh hopes, dreams and self-esteem – If you discounted the fact that a Welsh side would have finally qualified for a tournament the championships probably wouldn’t have meant much to me; the matches would be taking place in south Wales and I probably wouldn’t have been able to watch any of them – it’s a lament that UEFA decided to award the championships to Israel.

I’m not the only one that feels a sense of unease over this decision, a lot of people wondered how you could host a tournament in Israel, a country where this kind of situation exists;

“Palestinians are continually under attack from the Israeli occupying forces and are increasingly harassed by settlers, who attack farmers and steal their land. Collective punishments, such as prolonged curfews and house demolitions are frequently imposed.

The Palestinians who remained in what is today the state of Israel, as non-Jewish members of a Jewish country, also face discrimination in all areas of Palestine and are considered to be second class citizens.”

Naturally a boycott was called for;

Petition: Stop Israel hosting UEFA U21s Championship

Sports Boycott

Historically, the sports boycott effectively sent a message to Apartheid South Africa that the international community did not accept her racist policies. The sports boycott tool can be used to send a message to Israel.

Most sports competitions sign up to the doctrine of ‘fair play’ yet they allow Israel to take part in these competitions despite the fact that Israel routinely continues to impede Palestinian sportsmen from the same participation. Sports boycott, like the cultural boycott exposes Israel’s violations on an international platform, preventing Israel’s efforts to falsely portray itself as a normal state.

Sign Petition to stop Israel hosting UEFA U21s 2013

Israel has been awarded the privilege to host the UEFA U21 Championship 2013. We would like you to sign the petition, which we will send to the President of UEFA, Mr Michel Platini to reverse its decision.

We, the undersigned ask UEFA to reverse its decision to grant Israel to host the UEFA U21 Championship 2013. Historically, the sports boycott effectively sent a message to Apartheid South Africa that the international community did not accept her racist policies. We would like UEFA to reverse its decision to send a message to Israel that civil society around the world does not accept its Apartheid policies and that it should end its illegal occupation of Palestine.”

In case you’re unaware of the case for a boycott, look at this page again or here. Of course there is another side ;

Uefa slaps down bid to boycott Israel 2013

Protests marred the Israeli women's football match against Scotland
Protests marred the Israeli women’s football match against Scotland

Uefa president Michel Platini has rejected calls to strip Israel of a high-profile football tournament and rebuked the Palestinian Football Association for lobbying against Israel.

Next year’s European Under-21 Championship will go ahead as planned — despite what Mr Platini called “a certain amount of pressure being put on us”.

In a strongly worded rebuke to the president of the Palestinian FA, Mr Plarini rejected his demands and said that Uefa did not believe in “punishing people and isolating them”.

Activists, including former Leeds and Manchester United player Eric Cantona and former West Ham United and Tottenham striker Frédéric Kanouté, had joined the call on Uefa to move the tournament from Israel as a punishment for the detention of a number of Palestinian footballers without trial or charge.

Mr Cantona wrote to Uefa claiming: “Racism, human rights abuses and gross violations of international law are daily occurrences in that country.

“It is time to end Israel’s impunity and to insist on the same standards of equality, justice and respect for international law that we demand of other states.”

Mr Platini rejected the boycott calls in a letter to Israel FA chairman Avi Luzon on Monday.

He wrote that Israel had “earned the right to host the competition through a fair, democratic vote”.

The campaign centred on the case of Palestinian national team footballer Mahmoud Sarsak, who has been on hunger strike in an Israeli jail for three months.

He was detained without charge almost three years ago on suspicion of being an Islamic Jihad member. A deal to end his hunger strike was agreed on Monday and he is likely to be released next month.

Prior to that deal, Palestinian FA president Jibril Rajoub had written to Uefa claiming Israel was “in direct violation” of Fifa regulations. He wrote: “For athletes in Palestine there is no real freedom of movement and the risks of being detained or even killed are always looming before their eyes.”

In response, Mr Platini criticised Mr Rajoub for leaking his complaint to the media — a move he said was “ill-advised”.

“I was surprised to read in the press that you had written me a letter… I know you to be direct and frank, qualities which I greatly appreciate, but which it seems not all your advisers share.

“We cannot hold the Israel FA responsible for the political situation in the region or for legal procedures in place in its country. You know better than anyone that it is not by punishing people and isolating them that we achieve our aims. It is through dialogue that solutions are found.”

Mr Platini said International Olympic Committee president Jacques Rogge and Fifa president Sepp Blatter supported Uefa’s stance on Israel’s hosting of the tournament.

Mr Platini also revealed that he had asked Prince Ali Bin Al-Hussein of Jordan, a member of Fifa’s executive committee, to intervene in Mr Sarsak’s case.

Mr Luzon replied to Mr Platini on Tuesday: “We appreciate and thank you for your confidence in us and for your and Uefa’s support and confidence in the Israel FA. We will never forget that.”

The Israel FA chief said he had already approached relevant Israeli authorities in an attempt to raise concerns about Mr Sarsak’s situation.

Israel beat Bulgaria, Czech Republic, England and Wales to win the right to host the 2013 tournament – the under-21 version of the competition currently being played in Poland and Ukraine. It is likely to feature some of the world’s leading young players.

Mr Platini’s intervention came two days after Israel’s women’s side was barracked by protesters during a match in Edinburgh.

On Saturday, the Israelis played Scotland’s women in a qualifying match for Uefa’s 2013 Women’s European Championships at Hearts’ Tynecastle Stadium.

Among the 817 people in the stands was a group of around 200 anti-Israel protesters, who booed the Israelis’ every touch and chanted anti-Israel slogans for the duration of the match. The Israeli national anthem was also booed before kick-off.

When asked before the game about the intended protests, Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign chairman Mick Napier had refused to say whether the group would launch a pitch invasion, leading Uefa officials and Hearts to bring in extra police and security measures in an effort to ensure the protesters did not cause further disruption.

Israel lost 8-0 and is bottom of its qualifying group, having lost every game in the competition.
Defender Diana Radman criticised Uefa for allowing political protests inside the stadium during the game.

“I knew before we came that there would be protests and something would happen, but at previous games the officials did not allow protesters into the game. Uefa needs to act on this sort of abuse,” she said.

“There were players on both sides who were affected. It was not an easy experience. We were upset. This would never happen with the men. If anything happens in the stadium at a men’s international, then people are removed and the associations are fined”.

“It is hard enough getting people to come to watch women’s football. The protests are very damaging. In France we had people invade the pitch.”

Ms Radman said her team-mates had not considered walking off the pitch as the abuse continued. “As players, we will play no matter what. But after the game I wanted to get to the locker-room quickly. We should not have to worry about things that are political; we just want to play.”

There were further protests when Israel played Wales’ women’s team in Wrexham on Wednesday evening.

Members of the Wrexham Peace and Justice Forum had called on the Welsh players to boycott the match, and invoked Israel’s security barrier to encourage fans to imagine Wrexham separated by an eight-foot-high wall.

Following a demonstration outside the Racecourse Ground, stewards and police stopped a number of protesters entering the stadium before kick off. Others were evicted during the game, which Israel lost 5-0.

Diana Radman may criticize UEFA “for allowing political protests inside the stadium during the game” but I wonder if the Israeli media has ever exposed her to the situation that Palestinians have to put up with. Does she knows about the situation that female Palestinian footballers, footballers just like her, have to face simply because they happen to be Palestinian?

If she chose to wonder about these issues the short film that was posted on the When Saturday Comes website earlier today would provide some useful knowledge.

The situation looks eerily familiar to the one I saw depicted in another programme about Palestinian footballers (This one’s from about eight years ago);

They didn’t award a football tournament to Apartheid-era South Africa why did they feel that is was fine to award one to Israel?




One response

23 02 2014
They can obviously do without me……Like I care! | XXXXXXXXX Jet Set

[…] is the problem for obvious reasons so I’ll give that trip a swerve. I’m not sure how comfortable I would be doing the […]

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: